Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement
On December 13, 2016, President Obama signed the 21st Century Cures Act into law. The new law will allow small employers that do not offer any group health plan to their employees to adopt a Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA) to reimburse employees for premiums they pay for individual insurance policies. The new law is effective January 1, 2017.
NOTE: QSEHRAs are an exception to the ACA requirements and are not part of the ACA. Even if the ACA is repealed and replaced, it is expected that QSEHRA’s will remain valid.
Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), small employers (those with less than 50 full-time employees, counting full-time equivalents) are not subject to penalties for failing to provide group health plan coverage to their employees. As a result of this exception, as well as the substantial costs of group health plan coverage, many small employers do not offer such coverage. However, many small employers have wanted to do something to help their employees, such as reimbursing employees for premiums they pay for health insurance policies obtained in the individual market. Unfortunately, 2013 guidance from the IRS (Notice 2013-54) ruled that such an arrangement violated the market reform provisions of the ACA, regardless of whether the reimbursements were treated as taxable or not. Since violations of the ACA market reform provisions subject an employer to excise taxes of $100 per day per employee, sponsoring a prohibited reimbursement arrangement could have been a very costly mistake (although the new law also offers some relief in this area for 2015 and 2016).
The new law provides that a QSEHRA will not be considered a group health plan for ACA purposes, such that it will be exempt from the market reform requirements. To qualify as a QSEHRA, the program must meet the following requirements:
- A QSEHRA must be funded exclusively with employer contributions; there is no provision for employee contributions (such as those made under a typical Section 125 cafeteria plan).
- Reimbursements must be limited to $4,950 per year for employee-only coverage and $10,000 per year for family coverage.
- A QSEHRA must be offered to all eligible employees on the same terms. (Exclusions are permitted for employees with less than 90 days of service, employees under age 25, employees covered by a collective bargaining agreement, non-resident aliens, and certain part-time and seasonal employees.)
- The employer cannot offer group health plan coverage to any of its employees.
See also: QSEHRA Frequently Asked Questions
QSEHRA Notice Requirements
An employer that adopts a QSEHRA must provide a written notice of the availability of the QSEHRA to each eligible employee at least 90 days before the beginning of each year. While special rules for 2017 and 2018 allowed for later deadlines (since QSEHRAs were new and the rules were still being developed), no special deadline is available for a QSEHRA providing benefits in 2019. Therefore, an employer providing a QSEHRA for 2019 must provide the written notice no later than October 3, 2018.
An employer desiring to offer a QSEHRA will need a written plan document setting forth the terms of the arrangement, along with supporting documents. For a plan document package that meets the requirements of the law, please contact Gary Gunnett at (412) 288-2210 or [email protected].
As a result of the 21st Century Cures Act that was signed into law in December of 2016, small employers are now permitted to reimburse employees for premiums paid for individual health insurance policies, effective January 1, 2017, under a new type of plan called a Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangement (QSEHRA). Prior to the new law, these types of arrangements had been prohibited by the Affordable Care Act (ACA).
Since small employers – defined as having less than 50 full-time equivalent employees – were not subject to penalties for failing to provide group health plan coverage under the ACA, many opted out of providing coverage to their employees because they found it cost prohibitive to do so. Yet, many still wanted to help their employees with their individual health care premiums. The QSEHRA is one way for small employers to provide health insurance assistance to their employees.
Several requirements need to be met for the plan to qualify as a QSEHRA. In order to help small employers easily and efficiently adopt a QSEHRA, Houston Harbaugh’s Employee Benefits/ERISA Practice is pleased to make available a plan document package containing all of the documents needed to properly establish a QSEHRA. Included in the package are:
- a plan document compliant with all requirements of the new law,
- the special QSEHRA notice required to be provided to employees, and
- a Summary Plan Description meeting ERISA disclosure requirements.
The plan document package is not “one-size-fits-all.” Preparation of the QSEHRA plan document requires the employer to make several elections. Regardless of the elections chosen, the document package is offered at a flat fee rate.
For more information or to request the QSEHRA plan document package, contact Gary J. Gunnett at
[email protected] or 412-288-2210.
It is important to note that QSEHRAs are an exception to the ACA requirements and are not part of the ACA. Even if the ACA is repealed and replaced, it is expected that QSEHRA’s will remain valid.
Qualified Small Employer Health Reimbursement Arrangements (QSEHRAs) first became available in 2017 under a new law passed in December 2016. In October 2017, the IRS issued comprehensive guidance (Notice 2017-67) on the rules governing QSEHRAs, generally effective in 2018. The following FAQs summarize the current rules applicable to QSEHRAs:
What is a QSEHRA?
A QSEHRA is an employer-sponsored employee benefit plan under which the employer reimburses employees for medical expenses incurred by the employees and their family members, subject to certain limitations and other rules.
Why adopt a QSEHRA?
After the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and the implementation of new markets providing individual health insurance policies, some employers that did not sponsor group health plans for their employees sought to help employees pay for the cost of their individual policies by reimbursing them for premiums paid on the policies. However, the IRS and other government agencies found that these “employer payment plans” constituted group health plans, and because they failed to meet all of the rules applicable to group health plans under the ACA, they were non-compliant plans for which the employer could be subject to excise taxes of $100 per employee per day. (See IRS Notice 2013-54.)
The QSEHRA was specifically created as a solution to the above-described dilemma, i.e., a way that employers could reimburse employees for premiums for individual health insurance policies and other medical expenses without running afoul of ACA requirements.
Which employers are eligible to adopt a QSEHRA?
An employer is eligible to adopt a QSEHRA only if (a) the employer had less than 50 full-time employees (counting full-time equivalents) in the prior calendar year, and (b) the employer does not maintain any group health plan covering any employees. For this purpose, the term “group health plan” is construed broadly to include plans such as dental plans, vision plans, and health flexible spending arrangements (FSAs) that are part of Section 125 cafeteria plans.
Who funds a QSEHRA?
Under a QSEHRA, the cost of the reimbursements for medical expense must be funded exclusively by the employer. No reimbursements can be funded via employee salary reduction contributions, such as those traditionally made under a flexible spending arrangement (FSA) that is part of a Section 125 cafeteria plan.
What are the limits under a QSEHRA?
Reimbursements to an employee under a QSEHRA are limited to $4,950 per year for single coverage, or $10,000 per year for family coverage. (These statutory limits are adjusted for inflation each year. While the $4,950 limit remains unchanged for 2017, the $10,000 limit has already been adjusted to $10,050 for 2017. For 2018, the applicable limits are $5,050 and $10,250, respectively.)
The above-referenced limits are the maximums permitted under the law. However, an employer is free to design its QSEHRA to provide for any lower limits it might wish to impose. Also, an employer need not have a separate limit for family coverage. For example, an employer might wish to have a limit of $5,000 per employee in 2018, without regard to whether the employee’s policy is for single coverage or family coverage.
The annual limits must be prorated for an employee who is not covered by the QSEHRA for the entire year. For example, an employee who begins participation in the QSEHRA on May 1, 2018 with single coverage would be subject to a limit of $3,366.67 ($5,050 x 8/12) for 2018.
Since the dollar limits for an ensuing year are not expected to be published before mid-October, and the notice required to be provided to employees is generally due 90 days before the beginning of the new year (October 2), a QSEHRA is permitted to use the dollar limits for the prior year in lieu of the limits for the current year, if the QSEHRA document is written to so provide.
Which employees must be covered under a QSEHRA?
Generally, if an employer adopts a QSEHRA, all employees of the employer must be eligible to participate in the QSEHRA. However, an employee in any of the following specific categories can be excluded: (a) employees who have not completed 90 days of service with the employer, (b) employees who have not reached age 25 before the first day of the plan year, (c) part-time employees, (d) seasonal employees, (e) union employees for whom health benefits were the subject of good faith bargaining, and (f) nonresident aliens with no income from sources within the United States. Generally, “part-time” is defined to mean customary weekly employment of less than 25 hours.
Each of the above exclusions is permitted but not required in a QSEHRA. If an employer wants to design its QSEHRA to exclude some of the above-listed categories but not all of them, it is free to do so. For example, an employer might want to cover all employees without regard to age, or might want to cover employees immediately upon hire (i.e., without regard to the 90 day requirement).
Which employees cannot be covered under a QSEHRA?
A QSEHRA is not permitted to cover former employees (e.g., retirees) or owners of a business who are not considered to be employees.
May a QSEHRA provide different levels of benefits to different categories of employees?
Generally, a QSEHRA must be provided on the same terms to all eligible employees. However, the “same terms” requirement is not deemed to be violated if the maximum reimbursement under the QSEHRA varies from employee to employee based on the age of covered individuals or the number of individuals covered, in accordance with the variation in price of an insurance policy in the relevant individual health insurance market.
Which medical expenses can be properly reimbursed under a QSEHRA?
The expenses that can be reimbursed under a QSEHRA include (a) premiums for individual health insurance policies, and (b) other expenses that constitute medical care expenses under Section 213 of the Internal Revenue Code. However, medical expenses incurred before the employee became a participant in the QSEHRA cannot be reimbursed.
The insurance premiums that are reimbursed can include those for Medicare or Medicare supplement (Medigap) policies. Also, if the terms of the QSEHRA permit, premiums related to an employee’s family member can be reimbursed even if the policy covering the family member is not the same policy that covers the employee. Finally, a QSEHRA may reimburse premiums for coverage under a group health plan sponsored by the employer of the employee’s spouse. However, if the premium was paid on a pre-tax basis (as would normally be the case if the spouse’s employer maintains a cafeteria plan), the reimbursement from the QSEHRA is taxable to the employee.
Over-the-counter drugs purchased without a prescription can be reimbursed by a QSEHRA, if the terms of the QSEHRA so provide. However, these reimbursements are taxable to the employee.
A QSEHRA need not be designed to cover all expenses that can be properly reimbursed under a QSEHRA. For example, in the interest of simplicity, a QSEHRA can be written to cover premiums for individual health insurance policies only.
Can a QSEHRA provide for carryover of unused reimbursements from one plan year to the next?
Yes, a QSEHRA can be designed (but is not required) to permit a carryover of unused reimbursement amounts from one plan year to the next, but the sum of the carryover amount and the amount regularly available in the next year cannot exceed the dollar limit for the next year. For example, a QSEHRA that imposes an annual limit of $2,000 can permit a carryover of any unused amount, such that an employee who does not have any reimbursements in year one would be eligible for $4,000 in reimbursements in year two. However, no carryover is permitted in a QSEHRA that provides for annual limits equal to the maximums permitted for each year, as such an arrangement would automatically violate the annual limits in year two.
Can a QSEHRA provide for cash-out of unused reimbursements?
No, amounts that are available under a QSEHRA but go unused by the employee (and are not carried over) are lost forever. The QSEHRA rules do not permit any cash-out of unused amounts.
What are the requirements for notices to employees?
Generally, an employer who provides a QSEHRA to its employees must provide a written notice describing the QSEHRA at least 90 days before the beginning of each plan year (i.e., not later than October 2 for a QSEHRA operating on the calendar year). However, there are a couple of exceptions. First, in the case of an employee who is not eligible to participate in the QSEHRA at the beginning of the year, the notice must be provided no later than the date on which the employee is first eligible to participate in the QSEHRA. Second, because complete guidance on the notice requirements was not issued by the IRS until October 2017 (via Notice 2017-67), the notice for a QSEHRA provided for 2017 and/or 2018 is deemed to be timely if provided not later than February 19, 2018. Employers providing a QSEHERA for 2019 must provide written notice no later than October 3, 2018.
Reminder of Annual QSEHRA Notice Requirement 2018
The tax code imposes a penalty of $50 per employee (up to a maximum of $2,500 per year) on any employer that provides a QSEHRA but fails to provide the notice in a timely manner. Thus, employers should implement procedures ensuring that the notice is provided by the applicable deadline each year, and to all new employees who become eligible during the year, prior to eligibility.
The content of the written notice must include (a) a statement of the amount of each permitted benefit for which the employee might be eligible, (b) a statement that the employee must inform any Marketplace to which the employee applies for advance payments of the premium tax credit (PTC) of the amount of the permitted benefit, and (c) a statement that if the employee does not have minimum essential coverage (MEC) for any month, the employee may be liable for an individual shared responsibility payment for that month, and reimbursements under the QSEHRA for expenses incurred during that month will be included in the employee’s taxable income. A model notice that can be used to satisfy the requirements is included as an appendix to Notice 2017-67.
What proof of coverage is required for a QSEHRA to make reimbursements?
A QSEHRA may provide for reimbursement only after the eligible employee provides proof that the employee (and the individual whose expense will be reimbursed, in the case of a family member) has minimum essential coverage (MEC) for the month in which the expense is incurred. The proof must consist of either (a) a document from a third party, such as the insurer, evidencing coverage (e.g., an insurance card or explanation of benefits) accompanied by an attestation by the employee that the coverage is MEC, or (b) an attestation by the employee stating that the employee and the individual have MEC, the date coverage began, and the name of the provider of the coverage. A model attestation that can be used to satisfy the requirements is included as an appendix to Notice 2017-67. Initial proof of MEC must be provided at least annually, and following the initial proof of coverage for a year, an attestation of ongoing MEC coverage must be provided with each request for reimbursement.
How must claims for reimbursement under a QSEHRA be substantiated?
To ensure that a payment under a QSEHRA is for a proper medical expense, the claim for reimbursement must be “substantiated,” using methods similar to those required with respect to flexible spending accounts (FSAs) under cafeteria plans. If a QSEHRA mistakenly reimburses an employee for a medical expense that has not been substantiated, all subsequent payments to all employees under the QSEHRA become taxable. However, the substantiation failure can be cured, and the tax-free nature of other payments under the QSEHRA can be preserved, provided that the employee either repays the unsubstantiated amount (with after-tax dollars) or provides the required substantiation not later than March 15 in the following year.
What reporting must be done with respects to reimbursements under a QSEHRA?
Reimbursements under a QSEHRA are generally excluded from the employee’s taxable income. However, the employee’s permitted benefit is required to be reported on the employee’s Form W-2. For this purpose, the “permitted benefit” is the amount the employee was entitled to receive under the QSEHRA, and not the reimbursements actually received. This amount is to be reported in box 12 of Form W-2 using code FF. Special rules apply when reimbursements under a QSEHRA are taxable, such as when over-the-counter drugs without a prescription are reimbursed, or premiums paid on a pre-tax basis for coverage under a group health plan maintained by the spouse’s employer are reimbursed by the QSEHRA.
What happens if a QSEHRA is not operated in accordance with all of the rules?
If an arrangement fails to be a QSEHRA because one or more of the QSEHRA requirements are not satisfied, the arrangement constitutes a noncompliant group health plan subject to the ACA, with resulting excise taxes of $100 per affected person per day. Therefore, an employer should adopt a QSEHRA only if it is prepared to operate the QSEHRA in full compliance with all of the QSEHRA requirements.
Is a QSEHRA subject to PCORTF fees?
Self-insured health plans are generally subject to the ACA requirement to pay Patient-Centered Outcomes Research Trust Fund (PCORTF) fees. A QSEHRA qualifies as a self-insured health plan for this purpose. The fee is reported on Form 720, which is due on July 31 of the year after the plan year (e.g., July 31, 2018 for a QSEHRA maintained during 2017). The fee for 2017 is $2.38 times the average number of covered lives under the plan.
The good news is that PCORTF fees are only applicable for plan years ending before October 1, 2019. Therefore, for a calendar year QSEHRA, 2018 will be the last year for which the fee has to be paid.
An employer desiring to offer a QSEHRA will need a written plan document setting forth the terms of the arrangement, along with supporting documents. For a plan document package that meets the requirements of the law, please contact Gary Gunnett at (412) 288-2210 or
“Over the years, Gary has been a trusted advisor; knowledgeable and supportive, timely and efficient. He has helped us countless times with his guidance and insight. In today’s environment, where it can be rare to have a professional relationship endure, DDI has been privileged to have a solid, lasting and beneficial relationship.”
Dave Thomas, CEBS, Manager, Benefits, Development Dimensions International, Inc. (DDI)
“[Gary] helped me navigate the complexity of the regulations and made a daunting project [merger of existing 401(k) plans] much more manageable, one that ended up being well received and successful. [Gary] has the unique ability of providing useful and reliable guidance on issues that can be very technical in nature, all while keeping it in terms that a non-legal professional can understand.”
-Jamie O’Neill, Manager, Compensation, HR Systems and Retirement, LB Foster
“Gary is prompt with his response in anything that I have asked him. Very knowledgeable in answering any questions I have and explains them well. I would recommend his services to anyone.”
-Mary Alice Grusch, Pension Coordinator, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
“Gary’s expertise, combined with his sense of urgency in responding to our issues and concerns, has provided the foundation for a relationship that has continued for over 15 years. His competence and ability to communicate at all levels have allowed him to successfully lead our company through some very complex decisions with regard to our retirement plan program.”
-Donna Cree, Benefits Manager, Ward Transport & Logistics Corp
“ESB Bank has entrusted Houston Harbaugh, and specifically Gary Gunnett, to handle legal aspects of our employee benefits plans since 1995. We have been extremely pleased with Gary’s knowledge of employee benefit laws and regulations and, more importantly, how to best insure that our plans are in compliance.
Gary is quick to respond to inquiries, address pertinent issues, takes a proactive stance on keeping me current with plan issues and deadlines, and does so at a competitive price. He has an excellent working relationship with our ESOP record keeper, which has proven to be a valuable plus.”
-John T. Studna, Senior Vice President – Human Resources, ESB Bank
“As we celebrate our 50th year in business, we are happy to acknowledge both Gary and his firm as being extremely instrumental to our success. We have worked with Houston Harbaugh since 1975 and with Gary since 1990. Gary is a learned, competent and highly-responsive advisor and trusted friend to me and our group of companies.”
-Mark S. Lock, President, Chartiers Enterprises, Inc., parent company of Atlas Industries et al.